The Cottonwood Heights City Council unanimously voted Oct. 20 to shelve plans for a police training gun range near City Hall, citing resident pushback over noise, lead pollution and cost.

Council Member Matt Holton, who had helped pursue federal funding for the facility, moved to table Resolution 2026-69 and Resolution 2026-70 "to a date uncertain." Council Member Suzanne Hyland seconded the motion. All members present voted in favor.

The two resolutions covered a Public Safety Range Grant Agreement and a contract with Milo, the range's technology provider. Holton said there had been "great engagement with residents who live near the proposed police training facility site at the police station" and asked for time for additional feedback and potential mitigation efforts.

Birrell's opposition

Council Member Ellen Birrell read a prepared statement at the work session opposing the project. She said the proposed location, adjacent to the City Hall community meeting room and Cottonwood Heights Police Department headquarters, sat in a residential area near Brighton High School.

Birrell said the council had earlier supported the project when it was announced for the Public Works complex, farther from homes. She called the new site unacceptable.

She listed four concerns. First, financial risk: the council had recently raised property taxes by 42%, and a $150,000 budget adjustment to commit to the project conflicted with new fiscal guardrails. Second, the city was managing $2 million in unexpected storm drain failures since Aug. 13 alongside lean staffing. Third, she wanted an independent financial analysis before any commitment. Fourth, she cited noise data showing the modular range would produce sound eight decibels above ambient levels, which she said exceeds the threshold where public complaints begin.

Birrell also raised concerns about residual lead pollution in the air near the site, noting high school students cut through the City Hall parking lot.

She said the city should postpone the project until an outside firm or the Citizen Budget Committee completed a 10-year financial analysis. She also asked staff to explore placing the regional facility outside the city in partnership with a neighboring jurisdiction.

Holton defends the concept

Holton acknowledged the city's tight finances but said the Milo range offered training capabilities a traditional range could not, including scenario-based exercises for live-fire incidents at Brighton High School and mental health episodes. He called it "sad to lose the opportunity."

Council Member Shawn Newell pointed to the Tactical Penguin gun range near Sam's Club, saying a residence sits directly behind it and "very little sound came out of the range regardless." He said the Milo facility had superior noise-reducing technology.

Mayor Gay Lynn Bennion expressed gratitude that Holton asked to table the items. She said she was concerned there had not been adequate public engagement on the issue.

The grant funding from the Department of Justice Byrne Discretionary Community Project Grant was still pending at the time of the vote, according to Birrell's statement. No date has been set to revisit the resolutions.